Rebuilding trust
What happens when the relationships that underpin effective teamwork begin to break down?

I have been reflecting on this question while facilitating an IB Category 3 online workshop on Leading and managing teams, where we are exploring strategies for overcoming team dysfunction. The question has become particularly pertinent following my work this week in a school in Scandinavia, where relationships had deteriorated both within the staffroom and between staff and school leadership. It was a timely reminder that collaboration, trust and collective responsibility cannot simply be assumed.
Why do some teams struggle to work effectively together?
Patrick Lencioni's The Five Dysfunctions of a Team provides a useful framework, identifying five interconnected challenges: absence of trust, fear of conflict, lack of commitment, avoidance of accountability and inattention to results. At the foundation is trust. Without it, people are reluctant to be vulnerable, admit mistakes or express disagreement. Difficult conversations are avoided, commitments become fragile and collective purpose is lost. Amy Edmondson's research on psychological safety reinforces the importance of creating environments where people feel able to take interpersonal risks without fear of embarrassment or punishment. Trust, however, is more than getting along: it requires both genuine care for colleagues and the confidence that people will do what they say they will do.
So, how do we begin to rebuild trust and a sense of collective purpose?
My recent experience has reinforced the importance of relational intelligence. For me, this involves several interconnected leadership practices:
- Lead with authenticity. Be prepared to show vulnerability, acknowledge mistakes and recognise that you do not have all the answers. Trust begins with what we demonstrate, not simply what we ask of others.
- Create space for stories. Establish psychologically safe opportunities for people to share their experiences and perspectives, and, equally importantly, to listen to others without immediately judging, commenting or defending. In the school, we watched Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie's TED Talk, The Danger of a Single Story. It prompted us to recognise that we all have our own stories, assumptions and perceptions – some of which we recognise, others of which we may not even be aware. One of the most powerful outcomes was the appreciation people expressed for simply having the opportunity to listen to one another.
- Reimagine a shared purpose. Repairing relationships is important, but it is not enough. We also explored the need to revisit our mission – who we are and what we are here to do – and our vision – where we wish to go together. If we can centre these conversations on the needs of children, we have a much stronger basis for galvanising collective commitment.
- Understand the culture we want to change. We also drew on Culture Rewired, which highlights how schools contain multiple, sometimes competing, subcultures. Leaders cannot simply impose a new culture; they need to understand which existing stories and practices support the school's purpose, which need adapting and which need challenging. Changing the language of a school is relatively easy; changing deeply embedded behaviours and assumptions is much harder. As the book suggests, cultural change needs to become a school-wide movement, not simply an individual leadership initiative.
Ultimately, rebuilding a team is not about returning to how things were. It is about creating the conditions for something better: relationships built on trust, a willingness to engage in honest conversations and a renewed sense of collective identity and purpose. Perhaps the most important question for us as leaders is: What are we doing, through our everyday words and actions, to create a culture in which everyone can contribute, belong and work together in the best interests of our students?