Assessment - what is its purpose?
- IB Approaches to teaching and learning
- IB Approaches to Teaching
- Teaching is informed by assessment
- Assessment - what is its purpose?

Does assessment support learning or is it the enemy of learning?
"Assessment should be an opportunity to enhance, empower and celebrate students‘. Instead we too often use it as an opportunity to point out students’ failings.” (David Lazear, 1995)
This page will provide you with stimuli to relook and reimagine the role of assessment within your school.
Assessment has definitely been one of the most debated educational issues of 2018.
'Assessment' is Modern Learners provocation of the year. On the deficit side they reflect that assessment is “a word that has ... come to be detested by students... and exploited by politicians …The very fact that some twisted logic has allowed student high-stakes assessment to determine which teachers retain tenure or gain promotion, which schools should be closed while at the same time causing extreme student stress, undermines any pretence about learning, and completely belies any common sense.”
On a positive note a number of recent books have reimagined assessment: Beyond Testing (Meier & Knoester) describes alternative forms of assessments. The Test (Kamenetz) signposts a future of better tests that ensure that each child is more than a score. In his polemic The Testing Charade Daniel Koretz argues that the whole idea of standardised testing has become an end in itself, harming students and damaging the very ideals of teaching, and argues that we need to measure what matters, and measure it in multiple ways—not just via standardized tests.
It is not only educationalists who are challenging the role of traditional high-stakes standardised assessments. In his opinion piece for the New York Times Adam Grant observed that “Academic excellence is not a strong predictor of career excellence. Across industries, research shows that the correlation between grades and job performance is modest in the first year after college and trivial within a handful of years.”
Use one (or all) of the following quotes as a provocation to start discussion:
- “Assessment should be an unobtrusive servant of teaching and learning.” (Alfie Kohn, What does it mean to be well educated?, 2004)
"Student assessment is a process that helps focus attention towards what matters most in education: the learning outcomes of each student." (OECD)
"Children can and should understand and get information from assessments. It should help them to understand themselves better ... in a way that a simple grade can't." (Professor Peter Tymms, Tes 24 August 2018)
“Assessment – particularly teacher assessment - is one of the great unclaimed prizes of learning.” (Education Endowment Foundation)
"I have reviewed more than 300 studies of K–12 academic tests. What I have discovered is startling. Most tests used to evaluate students, teachers, and school districts predict almost nothing except the likelihood of achieving similar scores on subsequent tests.” (Susan Engel).#
You could also show this rather shocking video to engage staff in thinking about the nature of assessment:
- How does this form of assessment resonate with your views | practices of assessment?
- What are the pros/cons of this assessment?
- How could you modify this task to increase student success/engagement?
Reflections
- Key to successful assessment | learning is feedback. This video shows the case of students getting negative feedback. What does this make them feel? All they got here was feedback - not feed-forward.
- Assessment is relational - is there a culture of trust. The assessment must be transparent.
- This video shows a lack of assessment criteria. But one of the challenges of criterion referenced assessment is that it needs to be fair.
“The research is very clear that assessment is crucial to teaching. If I'm not assessing I may be teaching but I can never know what students are learning and the evidence on feedback is that it's one of the most powerful things we can do to help students improve, but it's also particularly hard to get right. I think we often mix up feedback and marking. Feedback is like a thermostat; it changes what the radiator does so we reach a desired temperature. For example, if I write comments but students don't act on them, don't understand them, don't even read them then I'm marking but I'm not giving feedback.” (Harry Fletcher-Wood, Institute for Teaching)
What do we mean by assessment?
The IB have published an excellent introduction to assessment in their PYP material. You can find it by going to ‘My IB’ | PYP resources |Learning and Teaching | Assessment
In summary:
- Assessment is an ongoing process of gathering, analysing, reflecting and acting on evidence of student learning to inform teaching.
- Assessment involves teachers and students collaborating to monitor, document, measure, report and adjust learning.
- Students actively engage in assessing and reflecting on their learning, acting on feedback from peers and teachers to feed forward to next steps in learning.
- Fostering an assessment culture involves the development of assessment capability among all members of the learning community.
- Learning goals and success criteria are co-constructed and clearly communicated
- Both learning outcomes and the learning process are assessed.
- Assessment design is both backward and forward looking.
text
- List all the ways you have assessed students in the last two weeks.
- Share in groups
- Identify the most common ways you assess students
- Discuss and agree a definition of educational assessment.
Discuss the following definition - to what extent it is a good definition?
"Assessment is a central process in education. It is through assessment that we can find out whether students have learned what they have been taught, so that we can make appropriate adjustments to our teaching. Assessments are used to describe the achievements of students, so that decisions can be made about their suitability for jobs, or the kinds of educational experiences that should follow." (Dylan Wiliam, 2008).

Assessment of student learning is very much a live and controversial issue, not least in countries which have high stakes testing regimes. Sometimes this is a national issue - in the US it is part of the No Child Left Behind policy; in the UK on-going continual assessment has been replaced with end of course high stakes exams for 16 and 18 year olds. Countries such as these use international test score comparisons to justify increasing standardized approaches to assessment and a return to elements of rote learning. However, many of the high performing educational jurisdictions do not use standardized testing until the secondary school, and then it is used to ensure students are in the correct form of education and also as a pre-university assessment of ability.
So what do you think the role of assessment is?
- Draft a preliminary explanation of the purpose of assessment
- Read the section on 'Informed by assessment' in the Approaches to Teaching section of the Approaches to Teaching and Learning guide.
- Reflect on the following: How does the IB define the role of assessment?
- Select key excerpts from the document as evidence of how the guide supports/extends your notion of the purpose of assessment.
- Share your response in whatever format makes sense to you – this could be using a graphic, text, video, mind-map etc
Assessments should themselves be learning experiences.
"Children can and should understand and get information from assessments. It should help them to understand themselves better, understand their progress and what their next stage in a way that a simple grade can't. If we're aiming for the good assessment about individuals, then the ideal assessment focuses on the strengths of pupils and where the next stage of learning should come from. It's best done with a computer, starting by probing with one question and moving to something harder only if they get it right. Weaker children shouldn't be faced with impossible questions and stringer children shouldn't be wasting their time." (Professor Peter Tymms, Tes 24 August 2018)
So what are the principles of good assessment?
- Read each of the statements on the PDF.
- Cut out and arrange the statements in order of importance.
- Add your own statements (if you think something is missing)
- Prioritize the statements using a Diamond 9 formation
- Discuss the relationship between the statements
- Draw conclusions for your own statement of 'good assessment'

Reflect on these 10 values:
- Where do these have a home in practice? What does it sound like, feel like, look like?
- Is there alignment across these values across my team / my school?
Use the following think piece as a way of re-imagining the role of assessment.
Modern Learners' 7 Assessment Strategies for schools of modern learning is a great freely downloadable ebook that will spark critical conversations around assessment in your school. It can be downloaded by following the link found HERE.
You could use the Jigsawing protocol to ask different groups focus on the following aspects of this white paper:
- The Dubious Roots of Testing (pages 3-7) argues that roots of high-stakes testing has very little to do with promoting learning.
- The Abused Learner and the Age of Absurdity (page 7-10) demonstrates the harmful effects of high-stakes tests in trying to measure student achievement, not only in the pressure they put on students and teachers but on the effect of narrowing the curriculum and ignoring the skills that matter for innovation and success (e.g. working with people of other cultures or complex thinking around global challenges).
- The Urgency for Change (pages 10-11) makes the case for changing how and what we assess so that we focus on what matters. The paper quotes Russell Ackoff: “The essential purpose of an educational system is to provide an environment that allows children to develop into successful adults. Replacing that with an educational system that forces children to perform well on a specific set of exams is nothing less than the end of schooling as a useful tool for society."
The heart of the document presents the following seven strategies for conversations concerning assessment. Each contains useful discussion questions and resources.
- Beliefs must drive assessment (pages 13-17): Our beliefs about how learning happens must drive assessment which is authentic and wherever possible connected to real-world problems. “In the world outside of classrooms, the “real world”, examinations are seldom used to determine the competence of people. Employees are usually evaluated by how well they perform on their jobs.” (Russell Ackoff, Turning Learning Right Side Up: Putting Education Back on Track).
- Challenge assumptions that influence assessment practice (pages 18-21) encourages us to question the culture around testing in our school and system: how do students benefits from assessments? Whjat value do they have outside the school walls?
- Communication beats compliance (pages 22-27) asks the question whether the testing regime in your school determines the culture of your school? What emphasis do you put on preparing for tests as opposed to developing learning? How do you communicate with students and parents about which assessments really matter and support learning?
- Provide more authentic and real-world choices (pages 28-31) asks schools to consider a diversity of assessment practices that are more authentic and meaningful and support learning (e.g. portfolios, exhibitions, skills-based micro-credentials).
- Let students learn about how they learn (pages 32-35). Examine the role of critique, self-assessment and peer-assessment in nurturing self-managing independent learners who can self-reflect and identify the next steps in their own learning.
- Measure what matters (pages 36-39). How do we ensure that assessment promotes a students' learning? This section explores formative assessment, what counts as good feedback and the role of the teacher who adapts their teaching to what students' need. "Formative assessment is instinctive, continuous, informal, and is totally focused on supporting the learner and their learning."
- Invest in trust (pages 40-44) argues for "a renaissance of professional judgement"
The Education Endowment Foundation provides an excellent introduction to assessment - albeit from a specific national (UK) standpoint. In their Assessment and Monitoring Pupil Progress Guide they provide a discussion on the role of assessment (as a 'powerful learning event'), guiding principles (dfor an assessment policy) the role of data - validity and reliability, the importance of baseline testing, amongst other good articles.
The Grade Network have produced a helpful guide that summarizes a lot of research around assessment: The ultimate guide to grading and feedback. Click HERE. This link also allows you to access an ebook - Leveraging Feedback: A school leader's guide to transforming school culture and student achievement.
In “Curriculum on the move: Reviewing the philosophy of assessment” (UNESCO), Conrad Hughes argues for a new approach to assessment:
“At the core of this movement is the idea that assessment for today’s world must change so that we move from an industrial approach to a human approach. This will allow many more stars to shine, many more students to spread their wings and fly…. Students are not items to be sorted from top to bottom, a humane social science based on human flourishing and diversity should look for the particularities, strengths and signature of each person and celebrate what they bring to the table not how well they perform on narrow tests that have been designed in an identical fashion for thousands of test takers.
The following three steps must be considered if we are to move to a new paradigm that puts learning first:
- Terminal examinations should be weighted in such a way that they count for no more than one third to, at most, half of an end of year grade
- Schools should be at liberty to design their own courses and celebrate student achievements on those courses without fear that this will not be accepted by universities. This means that universities have to show open-mindedness in accepting alternative transcripts and diplomas from a multiplicity of different institutions. This is real diversity in action
- Students should be able to curate their own stories in a portfolio-type fashion so as to own the narrative of their learning more actively and seriously.”
Tags: assessment