Recent posts View all
Home of real teaching & learning
  • Full support for teachers
  • Focus on critical thinking
  • Engaging classroom activities
  • Integrated student eBook
  • Assessed tasks / qBank
  • Practice exam questions

The InThinking Guarantee: Our sites are written by expert practitioners and not by AI

See our AI policy

Disclaimer: InThinking subject sites are neither endorsed by nor connected with the International Baccalaureate Organisation.

Don't miss out, find out!
IB Approved Workshops

Business Management
IB DP Category 1

Berlin, Germany, 30 October - 1 November 2026

Find out more
Business Management: A focus on internal assessment
IB DP Category 3

Barcelona, Spain, 12 - 14 February 2027

Find out more
Business Management
IB DP Category 2

Stockholm, Sweden, 7 - 9 May 2027

Find out more

Find all InThinking events at
inthinking.net

FT Schools - Visa & Mastercard's market leadership

FT Schools - Visa and Mastercard's market leadership

Introduction

European governments are proposing their own digital payments system to reduce reliance on Visa and Mastercard, two US multinational companies, dominating credit card transactions.

This article connects directly to several IB Business Management syllabus units, illustrating key themes of operations management, marketing, and ethics.

The article and exam questions can be found on the FT Schools website here.

IB Syllabus links

Syllabus unitKey ideas for discussion
BMT 3 - STEEPLE analysis
  • Discuss how market dominance gives Visa and Mastercard significant market power.
  • To what extent should governments intervene to increase competition in highly concentrated (non-competitive) markets?
1.3 Organizational objectives
  • Explore how Visa and Mastercard might balance profit maximization with its corporate social responsibilities (CSR).
  • Evaluate the role of corporate social responsibility (CSR) in highly concentrated markets.
1.5 Economies of scale
  • Examine how large-scale operations lower costs and strengthen the market position of Visa and Mastercard.
  • Consider the challenges new entrants face in competing with established multinational companies like Visa and Mastercard.
  • Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of market leadership for retailers and consumers using credit card payment systems.
4.1: Introduction to marketing
  • Explain the importance of market share for Visa and Mastercard.
  • Analyse the importance of market leadership for Visa and Mastercard.
Key concept - Ethics
  • Discuss the ethical issues around fairness and accessibility of essential financial services.
  • Discuss ethical considerations of high credit card fees or limited consumer choice.

Quizlet

Students can deepen their understanding of the ideas in this FT article and connect them to key terms from the IB Business Management syllabus by completing the accompanying Quizlet activity.

Use the drop-down menu to choose the format that best supports your learning, such as Flashcards, Match, Learn, Test, or Spell.


Paper 2 Exam Practice Questions

The European credit card payments market is dominated by Visa and Mastercard, which together control most card-based transactions. Their market leadership allows them to influence transaction fees, service standards, and access for commercial banks, retailers, and consumers.

Visa and Mastercard benefit from economies of scale, large-scale global operations, and strong brand loyalty, which make it difficult for new entrants to compete effectively. Barriers to entry, such as high fixed costs of technological infrastructure and digital networks, further reinforce their dominance. This supports the profitability of both companies and helps maintain their competitive position.

However, governments and regulators in Europe are increasingly encouraging alternatives providers in order to increase competition, improve consumer choice, and reduce the reliance on foreign-owned firms.

Ethical and social considerations are also important for Visa and Mastercard. They must consider corporate social responsibility (CSR) in addition to profit maximization, including fair access to financial services, consumer protection, and contributing positively to society.

Exam Practice Questions (1)
(a)Define the term market leadership.

[2 marks]

(b)Explain two benefits of brand loyalty for Visa and Mastercard.

[4 marks]

(c)Explain one benefit and one disadvantage to customers of the dominance of Visa and Mastercard in European markets.

[4 marks]

Exam Practice Questions (2)
(a)Define the term corporate social responsibility (CSR).

[2 marks]

(b)Explain two types of economies of scale that Visa and Mastercard are likely to benefit from.

[4 marks]

(c)Explain two benefits of market leadership for Visa and Mastercard.

[4 marks]

Teacher only box

Answers

Exam Practice Questions (1)

(a)  Define the term market leadership.  [2 marks]

Market leadership occurs when a business has the largest market share in a given market or industry and significant influence over prices or output.

Award [1] for a definition that shows limited knowledge of market share.

Award [2] for a definition that shows clear and accurate understanding of market share, similar to the example above.

(b)  Explain two benefits of brand loyalty for Visa and Mastercard.  [4 marks]

Possible benefits include:

  • Repeat usage by consumers and businesses - Strong brand loyalty encourages banks, retailers, and customers to continue using Visa or Mastercard, ensuring stable transaction volumes and incomes.
  • Competitive advantage - Trusted brands like Visa or Mastercard make it difficult for rivals or new payment systems to attract customers, helping them maintain market leadership.
  • Lower marketing costs - Established brand recognition for Visa and Mastercard reduces the need for extensive advertising to attract new users (retailers and customers).
  • Higher customer trust - Consumers associate the Visa and Mastercard brands with security and reliability in financial transactions so are more likely to use (and keep using) them for transactional payments.
  • Accept any other relevant benefit to Visa and Mastercard.

Mark as a 2 + 2.

(c)  Explain one benefit and one disadvantage to customers of the dominance of Visa and Mastercard in European markets.  [4 marks]

Benefits could include an explanation of:

  • Convenience and global acceptance of Visa and Mastercard credit cards for transactional payments.
  • Customers can use the same payment systems widely across many countries and retailers, making transactions easy, convenient, and reliable.

With few alternatives, disadvantages could include an explanation of:

  • Limited consumer choice
  • Potentially higher annual credit card fees for consumers
  • Higher transaction costs for retailers.

Mark as a 2 + 2.

Exam Practice Questions (2)

(a)  Define the term corporate social responsibility (CSR).  [2 marks]

Corporate social responsibility (CSR) is a business approach in which businesses consider the social, ethical, and environmental impacts of their activities or operations in addition to earning profits.

Award [1] for a definition that shows limited knowledge of CSR.

Award [2] for a definition that shows clear and accurate understanding of CSR, similar to the example above.

(b)  Explain two types of economies of scale that Visa and Mastercard are likely to benefit from.  [4 marks]

Possible answers include an explanation of any two of the following:

  • Technical economies of scale - Large transaction-processing systems allow Visa and Mastercard to process millions of payments efficiently, every day, reducing their average costs.
  • Marketing economies of scale - Advertising campaigns can be spread across global markets, lowering the average marketing cost per customer.
  • Financial economies of scale - As large multinational companies, Visa and Mastercard may access finance at lower interest rates due to their size and reputation.
  • Managerial economies of scale - As large firms, Visa and Mastercard can employ specialist managers and experts to improve efficiency and decision-making.

Mark as a 2 + 2.

Award [1] for identifying a relevant economy of scale and [1] for explaining this in the context of Visa and Mastercard, up to the maximum of [4].

(c)  Explain two benefits of market leadership for Visa and Mastercard.  [4 marks]

Possible answers include an explanation of any two of the following:

  • Greater pricing power - Market leaders may have greater influence over transaction fees charged to banks and retailers. HL candidates can also refer to the lower price elasticity of demand here.
  • Stronger brand recognition - Being market leaders increases consumer trust and reinforces brand loyalty, i.e., repeat usage by consumers and retail businesses.
  • Higher profitability - Large transaction volumes and economies of scale from being market leaders enables Visa and Mastercard to increase their profit margins.
  • Competitive advantage - Market leaders are harder for new competitors to challenge, including the proposed European alternative payment systems, due to the established networks and reputations of Visa and Mastercard.

Mark as a 2 + 2.

Award [1] for identifying a relevant benefits of market leadership and [1] for explaining this in the context of Visa and Mastercard, up to the maximum of [4].

Check out our other collaborative pieces with FT Schools by using the hyperlinks below:

All our collaborations with FT Schools include student-friendly versions of the FT articles (case studies), exam practice questions, and full mark schemes for teachers.

Paul Hoang
FT Schools teacher advisor for IB Business Management

Help