Responsibility
Psychologists study living beings, both animals and humans. As a result, they must follow ethical standards. These standards are not simply rules for carrying out experiments in labs. This means that psychologists must protect individuals in their care and treat them with respect.
Responsibility is a complex concept in psychology. It includes legal and professional responsibilities. Psychologists advocate for improving society, and they intervene to address false beliefs and social stigma.
Ethical Responsibility
Psychologists must adhere to ethical principles, as outlined in guidelines like the APA (American Psychological Association) Ethical Principles of Psychologists and Code of Conduct. Some of the ethical responsibilities include:
- Avoiding harm: Researchers must minimize any physical or psychological harm to participants.
- Confidentiality: Researchers must ensure that participants' data is kept confidential and used only for the purposes outlined in the study.
- Informed consent: Researchers must provide participants with comprehensive information about the nature of the study, its purpose, procedures, potential risks, and benefits. Consent must be voluntary, and participants should have the opportunity to ask questions. Consent forms should be clear, and researchers must obtain explicit agreement before proceeding.
- Right to withdraw: Participants must be aware that they have the right to withdraw from the study at any point without any negative consequences.
The use of case studies
Psychologists can learn a lot about behavior and cognition through case studies. These are longitudinal studies of individuals with unique behaviors due to an accident, illness, or genetic mutation.
Of course, all of the ethical responsibilities for research are required, but psychologists also have to be careful about the relationship that develops between them and the person being studied. Studies can continue for several years, even decades. What problems might that cause?
Watch the following video on the Galvin family. If you were asked to conduct a case study on the family when they were all alive and living in their home together, what concerns would you have regarding your and your team's responsibilities?
There are several concerns with the study of the Galvin family. They include but are not limited to:
- The longer the study goes on, the more difficult it may be for them to withdraw from the study.
- There may be a sense of objectification of the family members; they may be seen as “an object to be studied” rather than attempting to understand their feelings and personal struggles.
- In reporting on the family, this could lead to stereotyping about people living with schizophrenia. Not all people living with the disorder are violent. This would need to be communicated.
- If interviews are carried out, any videos or recordings should be confidential.
- The psychologist should not seek financial gain from the study of the family.
Marginalized groups
Sieber and Stanley (1988) define socially sensitive research as “studies in which there are potential consequences or implications, either directly for the participants in the research or for the class of individual represented by the research.”
Socially sensitive research often involves marginalized or underrepresented groups. Psychologists need to be culturally competent. Cultural competence is understanding and effectively interacting with people from different cultures. Failing to recognize cultural differences can lead to harmful misunderstandings or biased interpretations of research findings.
Watch the following video. How do the people in the video show a lack of cultural competence?
There are several examples in the video. They include but are not limited to:
- Stereotyping about race.
- Not allowing him to explain his situation. Assuming they know all about his culture/race.
- She compares him to “other men” she knows who have ended up in prison.
- The doctor assumes that an injury must be due to abuse until he meets the father.
- The social worker and teacher impose their language style on the child.
Research on sensitive issues can easily be influenced by researchers’ biases or societal prejudices, leading to biased outcomes that could reinforce harmful stereotypes.
Psychologists must engage in reflexivity—examining their own biases and preconceptions to ensure that these do not influence their work. They should also design their research to ensure that findings reflect a fair and balanced understanding of the issue.
Researchers should avoid treating these groups as "subjects" without engaging them in the research process or considering their needs.
Psychologists should involve community members in the research process, ensuring their voices are heard and the research aligns with their needs and interests. They also need to recognize the historical power imbalances that have led to trauma within marginalized communities. This can help build trust and ensure that the research has real-world relevance and positive outcomes.
Cultural competence: Indigenous communities
Indigenous Peoples in India comprise an estimated 104 million, or 8.6% of the national population. The Dongaria Kondh (photo) is just one example. The deep reverence and respect that the Dongria have for their gods, hills, and streams permeates every aspect of their lives.
When psychologists study Indigenous communities, they should be grounded in cultural competence, showing respect for Indigenous worldviews and traditional healing practices.
Some key aspects of cultural competence concerning Indigenous communities include:
Incorporation of Traditional Knowledge: Traditional healing practices, such as storytelling, ceremonies, and Elders’ wisdom, are often integral to Indigenous mental health. Psychologists should work with community members to incorporate these practices where appropriate.
Holistic Healing: Psychologists should consider a holistic approach, addressing not just mental health but also emotional, physical, and spiritual well-being. Respect for Indigenous spirituality is critical in providing culturally competent care.
Community-Centered Approaches: Psychologists should work with the community, focusing on collective well-being. Healing can often occur in group settings rather than individual ones, and community-based interventions may foster a stronger sense of belonging and connection.
Historical Trauma: Indigenous populations have experienced historical and intergenerational trauma due to colonization, forced assimilation, and systemic oppression. Psychological interventions should recognize and address these layers of trauma while offering culturally relevant healing strategies.
Avoid pathologizing Indigenous Beliefs: Psychologists need to avoid pathologizing Indigenous worldviews, such as seeing spiritual beliefs as inferior or indicative of mental health disorders.
Transferring our knowledge
If you were going to come up with a list of what psychologists should consider when working with people your age, what would be the guidelines you would recommend?
Responsibility to clients
Responsibility is relevant not only for psychological research but also an important consideration when psychologists work with clients. This may be a person coming in for treatment or working with the public to reform health or work policies.
Psychologists must work within the boundaries of their competence. This means providing services only in areas where they have appropriate training, experience, and qualifications. This includes informing potential clients of one's areas of competence so that clients can make informed decisions. A therapist should tell a client their therapy specialization as well as any types of clients that they do not feel confident treating - for example, people with drug addictions.
Other guidelines for psychologists include:
- Duty of care: Psychologists have a legal and moral responsibility to provide quality care to their clients. They must assess, diagnose, and treat clients using scientifically supported methods.
- Client autonomy: Psychologists must avoid imposing their personal values or influencing the client's decision-making inappropriately.
- Cultural sensitivity: Psychologists must be sensitive to their clients' cultural, social, and personal contexts and ensure that their services are inclusive and respectful.
- Promoting public welfare: Psychologists should contribute to the welfare of society by applying their expertise to address societal issues such as mental health awareness, education, and social justice.
Ethical standards in research: use of deception, informed consent, cost-benefit analysis, anonymity, debriefing, right to withdraw, protection from harm
Interaction with different samples: Use of animals; child participants; case studies of participants with mental illness, physical disability, or trauma; marginalized groups; consent by proxy.
Research in public spaces: research that does not require informed consent.
Socially sensitive issues: stigma, publication of findings, advocacy for public welfare.
Checking for understanding
What is the primary reason psychologists must adhere to ethical standards?
Ethical standards focus on protecting individuals, ensuring that participants are treated respectfully and not harmed during research.
Which of the following is NOT an ethical responsibility of psychologists?
While publication is important for sharing knowledge, it is not an ethical responsibility. Ethics focus on participants' rights and well-being.
Which of the following best describes a case study?
Case studies focus on an in-depth analysis of a single individual, especially when their experiences are unique.
What is a potential ethical concern when conducting a long-term case study?
.
Prolonged studies can lead to participants feeling objectified or detached from their personal identities.
What is "cultural competence" in psychology?
Cultural competence means being aware of and respecting cultural differences, ensuring research is sensitive and accurate.
Why should psychologists involve community members in research?
Community involvement helps ensure that the research is relevant and respectful of the community's values and needs.
Which of the following is an example of ethical responsibility toward clients?
Ethical responsibilities include using evidence-based approaches to ensure that clients receive effective and safe care.
When might the use of deception be considered ethical in psychological research?
Deception can be used ethically if it is crucial to the research design and does not cause harm to participants.
Why is it important for psychologists to work within their competence?
By working within their areas of expertise, psychologists ensure that they provide effective and appropriate care to clients.