Home of real teaching & learning
  • Full support for teachers
  • Focus on critical thinking
  • Engaging classroom activities
  • Integrated student eBook
  • Assessed tasks / qBank
  • Practice exam questions

The InThinking Guarantee: Our sites are written by expert practitioners and not by AI

See our AI policy

Disclaimer: InThinking subject sites are neither endorsed by nor connected with the International Baccalaureate Organisation.

Don't miss out, find out!

HL Essay: Small Things Like These

HL Essay

This Higher Level Essay explores how Claire Keegan's movement between past and present in Small Things Like These represents Furlong's developing sense of moral responsibility.

The essay offers a thoughtful and convincing interpretation of Furlong's moral journey, particularly the influence of his childhood experiences on his eventual decision to help the young woman at the convent. The student demonstrates good knowledge of the novel, selects relevant textual evidence and offers some perceptive analysis of Keegan's literary choices.

An important strength is the way the essay connects close analysis of language with the novel's wider moral concerns. Although the discussion does not always sustain its focus on narrative time, the argument remains coherent and purposeful.

This is a strong example of a successful Higher Level Essay. It also provides opportunities to consider how an already accomplished essay might be developed further through more sustained attention to its chosen literary focus.

The essay can also be seen by clicking the icon below.

How does Keegan’s use of the narrative time frame, from past to present, represent Furlong’s journey from individual responsibility to moral duty in ‘Small Things Like These?’

In Claire Keegan’s 2021 novel ‘Small Things Like These,’ the character of Furlong, a coal and timber merchant, is faced with a moral dilemma after finding a young woman locked in a shed at a church-run Magdalene laundry. As the novel progresses, Furlong is forced to choose between individual responsibility towards himself and his family, and the moral duty to help the girl. The novel is set in the deeply catholic town of 1980’s New Ross, where religious authority reigned unquestioned. Keegan portrays the authority held by the convent nuns as deeply rooted in every aspect of society, instilling fear and influencing many of Furlong’s decisions. Despite this, the underlying theme that runs throughout the novel is a hope driven by Furlong’s childhood memories of Mrs Wilson, the kind protestant widow who took in and cared for him. Jumps in narrative time frame between the present and Furlong’s memories allow Keegan to demonstrate to the audience that it is memory which drives his shift from individual responsibility to moral duty. Through this Keegan illustrates that Furlong’s memories of Mrs Wilson are the driving factor for his ethical shift from individual responsibility to moral duty.

Firstly, Keegan presents Furlong’s struggle as a sustained conflict between moral duty and individual responsibility, to demonstrate how the temptation to ignore justice competes with the imperative to act. Throughout the novel, Keegan utilises repetition to convey the internal struggle Furlong faces when choosing between wilful ignorance and confronting the nuns after finding the girl abused and imprisoned in a coal shed. Upon discovering her, Keegan repeats that “the ordinary part of him simply wanted to be rid of this and get on home,” reiterating the intensity of this desire. The use of the adjective ‘ordinary’ demonstrates that in Furlong’s society, the avoidance of moral duty is normalised, following societal expectations, whilst ‘part of him’ further alludes to Furlong’s internal dilemma and fragmented moral stance. Additionally, “rid of this” with ‘this’ used to describe the girl, utilises a dismissive tone reflecting the avoidant attitudes of the townspeople towards the Magdalene laundry women. Keegan deliberately uses ‘get on home’ to demonstrate to the audience that Furlong desires the secure individual responsibility of ‘home’ when faced with a duty which jeopardises it. This allows Keegan to echo the voice of Furlong’s wife, who states “we have to mind ourselves and our own home.” ‘Mind ourselves’ captures the broader New Ross tendency of deliberate ignorance when faced with the institutionalised mistreatment of the girls. It also demonstrates how characters with the most influence on Furlong seek to anchor him to a purely familial responsibility, emphasising how self-interest and the fear of disruption often override the imperative to act against injustice. This is further exemplified in “he felt his self-preservation and courage battling against each other.” The personification of the two sides of his moral conflict affirms their intensity, and the violent connotations of “battling” suggests not only the difficulty of his choice but also the profound stakes of deciding whether to uphold moral justice.

Moreover, Keegan’s shifting narrative allows her to illustrate how recollections of Furlong’s past exacerbate his moral conflict. This is represented throughout the novel by the intermittent surfacing of Furlong’s recollections of Mrs Wilson’s acts of kindness, and hence rejection of societal norms, which Furlong benefited from as an illegitimate child in a conservative society. Through Mrs Wilson’s characterisation as a rich, Protestant woman, Keegan conveys how her existence outside of the conservative, catholic societal structures of Furlong’s world allowed her to reject self-preservationist attitudes to help Furlong. This allows Keegan to further convey the morally constraining influence of New Ross’ societal standards on Furlong’s dilemma of helping or ignoring the girl. In reminiscence of Mrs Wilson, Furlong recalls, “never once did we go hungry,” highlighting that his own survival, as with the girl in the shed, depended solely on someone’s refusal to disregard the “ordinary” wilful ignorance present in New Ross. Thus, the next line “he reached out and pressed the bell (of the convent),” conveys not only this break in complacency but also a culmination of Mrs Wilsons’s kindness on Furlong, influencing him to confront the nuns. In essence, Keegan’s portrayal of Furlong’s ethical conflict exposes how he must grapple with the tension between complete self-preservation and confronting injustice, a defining difference in the shift from individual responsibility to moral duty.

Additionally, Keegan uses a changing narrative time frame between the present and Furlong’s memories of Mrs Wilson, to demonstrate how memory acts as a guiding force, transforming Furlong’s individual responsibility into an awareness of wider duty. This is evidenced throughout the novel, particularly in Keegan’s repeated utilisation of the phrase ‘never once’ to describe Mrs Wilson’s kindness, such as in “she never once regretted [taking him in].” This repetition emphasises her unwavering support of Furlong, juxtaposing his initial treatment of the girl in the convent, where he “left her there at the table with nothing before her.” Keegan deliberately uses the symbolism of "nothing before her” to demonstrate to the audience that, without help, the girls at the Magdalene laundries had no  prospects. This further illustrates the stigma surrounding the laundries as well as the apathy and complacent self-preservation of the townspeople towards the mistreatment of the laundry women. Towards the end of the novel, when helping the girl, Furlong thinks of “Mrs Wilson, of her daily kindnesses...which, when added up, amounted to a life.” This line allows Keegan to demonstrate that without Mrs Wilson’s “kindnesses” Furlong would not have the life he has or the opportunity to help the girl. Thus, Furlong’s journey is presented as an inheritance of responsibility. Keegan’s deliberate use of “a life” instead of the personal pronoun ‘his life’ allows her to demonstrate that this principle can be applied universally and is not unique to Furlong. Additionally, it contrasts the kindness of Mrs Wilson with the supposed benevolence of the Church, which has harmed the lives of the laundry women. In essence, Keegan utilises an interplay of past and present tense, memory and current action, to represent the influence of past experience on Furlong’s shift from individual responsibility to moral duty.

Finally, Keegan sets the novel during Christmas to magnify social hypocrisy within New Ross and intensify the internal conflict which causes Furlong’s shift from individual responsibility to moral duty. Early in the novel, Keegan writes that “Christmas was coming.” This short phrase highlights the importance of Christmas in the context of the novel, where in the deeply Catholic town of New Ross Christmas has connotations of religious and moral observance, as well as helping those less fortunate. Keegan presents this as deeply hypocritical when Furlong, after leaving the girl at the convent, had “gone on, like a hypocrite, to mass.” Whilst ‘mass’ denotes religious observance, the subordinate commas either side of “like a hypocrite” reflect Keegan’s aim to highlight the moral irony and hypocrisy in holding a religious service whilst ignoring the injustice suffered by the laundry women at the hands of religious leaders. This exemplifies the self-preservationist attitude that dominates the landscape of the novel. Additionally, Keegan writes that “always Christmas brought out the best and worst in people” to further critique this hypocrisy as well as reflect Furlong’s moral journey. After he attends mass and decides to help the girl, Keegan utilises the rhetorical question “was there any point in being alive without helping one another?” to externalize Furlong’s inner conflict and illustrate his moral turning point. This externalisation allows Keegan to directly involve the reader in Furlong’s dilemma and encourages us to question the nature of inequality and community. Keegan deliberately uses “one another” to transform Furlong’s previous sense of individual responsibility into a collective one, and “alive” to frame the question beyond a simple act of charity, to place moral duty at the centre of human life. Therefore, by placing Furlong’s ethical shift within the contradictions of Christmas in New Ross, Keegan demonstrates how tensions between Furlong’s desire for justice and social hypocrisy catalyse his shift from individual responsibility to moral duty.

To conclude, Keegan uses a shifting narrative time frame throughout the novel as well as significant narrative settings, such as Christmas, to allow Furlong’s ethical journey to unfold as both deeply personal and socially significant. Keegan utilises the novel’s shifting narrative structure to induce the reader to reflect upon how past experiences influence present action as well as the nature of collective complicity. Memories of Mrs Wilson, public complicity, and comparisons between himself and the Magdalene laundry women, force Furlong to confront the discord between normalised individual responsibility, common in New Ross, and his own desire to fight moral injustice. By utilising Christmas as the backdrop for the novel, Keegan is able to use a season embodying both charity and religious hypocrisy to intensify Furlong’s internal conflict and lead him to the eventual conclusion of moral duty. Ultimately, Keegan’s narrative choices illustrate that Furlong’s decisions are born from a culmination of memory and past kindnesses, even when it requires personal sacrifice.

Bibliography

Keegan, C (2021) Small Things Like These, Faber & Faber, London, UK

Marks and comments

Criterion A: Knowledge, understanding and interpretation (5 marks)
4 out of 5

The essay demonstrates good knowledge and understanding of the novel, offering a convincing interpretation of Furlong's developing moral consciousness. References to the text are well chosen and effectively support the argument. Some interpretations could be developed with greater nuance, but the essay demonstrates a strong engagement with the work and its implications.

Criterion B: Analysis and evaluation (5 marks)

4 out of 5

The essay contains effective and at times perceptive analysis of Keegan's literary choices. Although the essay makes relevant connections between memory and present action, there is scope for a more sustained investigation of Keegan's manipulation of narrative time. Some analytical points are also more convincing than others. Nevertheless, this is an accomplished piece of literary analysis.

Criterion C: Focus, organization and development (5 marks)
4 out of 5

The essay is clearly organized and develops a coherent argument about Furlong's movement from individual responsibility towards moral duty. 

Criterion D: Language (5 marks)
4 out of 5

The language is clear, generally accurate and appropriate to formal literary analysis. 

Title Photo by Nathan Fertig on Unsplash

All materials on this website are for the exclusive use of teachers and students at subscribing schools for the period of their subscription. Any unauthorised copying or posting of materials on other platforms is an infringement of our copyright and could result in your account being blocked and legal action being taken against you.

Help