Paper 2 Sample response (May 2026)

This is a strong Paper 2 response to the question on change. The candidate shows very good knowledge and understanding of the text, makes thoughtful and constructive reference to authorial choices, and the essay is cogently organised. There is room for a more developed comparative argument, perhaps, but certainly a good response to show your students and mark together.
The essay can be seen in the drop-down below, and/or downloaded as a PDF.
Question: Some literary works present characters who are capable or incapable of change. In what ways is this true in two works you have studied?
The literary works of both ‘‘The Scarlet Letter’’ by Nathanial Hawthorne and ‘Oedipus Tyrannus’ by Sophocles present characters who are capable and incapable of change regarding different aspects of their identity and relationship with society. In ‘The Scarlet Letter’, Hester Prynne faces punishment for her act of adultery, giving the reader the impression of certain condemnation throughout the entirety of the text. However, Hawthorne presents Hester as a character capable of redemption and change of identity through her actions and responses throughout the plot of the novel. Contrarily, Sophocles presents Oedipus as a character who lacks the ability to change his true identity, presented through the continuous motif of fate throughout the play. ‘The Scarlet Letter’ and ‘Oedipus Tyrannus’ present characters that are capable and incapable of change in the face of an unchanging society that governs moral and ethical standards through moral certainty and divine fate respectively. Both texts present an ability and inability to change characters' private and public identity within the eyes of their broader society through the utilisation of symbolism, dramatic irony, and broader reference to societal structure.
Firstly, both works present characters that are capable and incapable of change through the portrayal of their internal, private identity. In ‘The Scarlet Letter’, the symbolism of the letter A is used as a reference point for the reader to understand Puritan society's reflection on the character of Hester Prynne. During her initial exposure to the public, the letter is described as an "ignominious brand upon her breast", indicating that the symbol begins as a representation of shame and punishment. Hawthorne uses the letter in the initial stages of the novel to critique the nature of Puritan society and its attitude towards moral flexibility. He describes it as "a society where law and religion were almost identical," representing how the society that Hester resides within is morally fixed and incapable of open-minded thinking, presented by how the judicial system is governed by strict religious bodies rather than moral truth. However, the letter's symbolism changes throughout the novel, reflecting the changing internal moral truth of Hester. As the novel progresses, the letter transforms and stands for "able," as well as "angel." Hawthorne ties Hester's identity to the letter, stating "The Scarlet Letter was her passport into regions no other woman dared tread." This extract refers to how Hester's isolation from society acts as a medium for her to critique and evaluate the relationship between Puritan law and religion, presenting how Hester's relationship with society and thus her internal identity changes throughout the novel. Contrarily, Oedipus is presented as a character incapable of changes to his internal identity, reflected through the use of dramatic irony as well as the symbolism of sight. While sight is used in ‘The Scarlet Letter’ as a symbol for Puritan punishment and moral values, in ‘Oedipus Tyrannus’ it represents Oedipus's knowledge of his own unchanging identity. Sophocles manages to present Oedipus's inability to change his own identity through the use of absolute vocabulary such as when Tiresias states "You are blind to your own / your very own." The "own" that Tiresias refers to in the extract is Oedipus's identity and relationship with himself. Throughout the course of the play, it remains a constant that Oedipus has committed patricide and incest, reflecting his true identity as a sinner as unchanging in the face of Oedipus's attempts to discover himself. The symbolism of the plague of Thebes is used to refer to the nature of Oedipus's real identity and moral truth, motivating internal exploration that inevitably leads to his true identity being revealed. While the course of the play debates the nature of Oedipus's identity, it is obvious to the audience that his real identity is constant throughout, shown
through the use of dramatic irony when Oedipus says "I shall speak as one who is a stranger to this story." Rather than in ‘The Scarlet Letter’ where Hester's true identity is revealed at the start and slowly changed through her actions, Oedipus's true identity is not revealed until the climax at the end of the play when he blinds and exiles himself. The contrast between the presentation of change or lack of change of true identity reflects how both writers attempt to capture the nature of the society that surrounds the characters. Oedipus was always condemned by his true identity, revealíng him as a more static character incapable of true change, due to the significance and power of fate within the society in which he resides. Hester Prynne is shown to be more dynamic, allowing her to reflect and critique the nature of Puritan society as an external observer. Overall, while ‘The Scarlet Letter’ presents Hester as a character capable of changing her internal identity, ‘Oedipus Tyrannus’ shows the audience Oedipus's incapability in changing his own true identity.
Secondly, both the works of ‘The Scarlet Letter’ and ‘Oedipus Tyrannus’ show characters that are capable of changes to their public identity and their relationship with the greater society in the texts. The initial scenes of Oedipus present him as a powerful and respected ruler, holding power over the people of Thebes, which is shown when the Priest describes him as "all-powerful ruler" and "best of men." This representation of Oedipus's perspective of himself is later shown to be capable of change as he slowly becomes more aware of his unchanging true identity, presented through the contrast in description. This is first shown through his interactions with Tiresias, where the prophet states "You are the murderer you're looking for." The harsh dysphemistic nature of the statement reflects Oedipus's changing power dynamic with the people of Thebes. His initial confidence that he was "a stranger to this story" is shattered, leaving him doubting and questioning his own interpretation of his identity. In stark contrast, the character of Dimmesdale in ‘The Scarlet Letter’ reflects a journey of internal moral condemnation that derives itself from the guilt of hypocrisy. While Oedipus's interactions with the people of Thebes do not remain constant throughout the play, as shown by his transformation from king to blind exile,Hawthorne presents Dimmesdale as a symbol of a hypocritical patriarchal system as his social power remains unchanged despite his change in true identity as a sinner. This is presented through Dimmesdale's internal guilt building throughout the novel, reaching the climax where he reveals the scarred letter A on his chest on the scaffold. This is also shown by the doubt of his social standing and the guilt he faces from benefiting from a patriarchal structure of Puritan society, where he says "Or purify a man while myself has sinned." The contrast in religious imagery reflects the differences between Dimmesdale's public identity as one capable of "[purifying] a man" and his private identity as someone who "has sinned". Dimmesdale's praise from Puritan society in tandem with his lack of courage to confess his true identity is a presentation of how ‘The Scarlet Letter’ features characters who are incapable of change in the eyes of society. Despite the similarities between the true identities of Oedipus and Dimmesdale, presented through their shared acts of sin, the writer portrays big differences in their response. While Oedipus seeks to reveal his true identity his interpretation by society and public identity is slowly changed, Dimmesdale knows of his true identity continuously, but refuses to change his public identity as someone worthy of praise. In summary, the public interpretation of Oedipus's identity įs shown to change throughout the play, presented through the dialogue and use of dysphemistic tone between the characters. Whereas, Dimmesdales’ interpretation by Puritan society remains unchanged as he is incapable of confession of his sin.
Finally, both works present characters who are both capable and incapable of change in actions and attitude towards their greater society. In ‘The Scarlet Letter’ Hester's punishment is shown to motivate her towards charitable acts that attempt to repair her reputation among Puritan society. In contrast, ‘Oedipus Tyrannus’ shows how Oedipus's attitude towards others deteriorates as he falls into paranoia and anger. Hester's transformation of attitude towards others can be seen through her interpretation of her daughter, Pear. During The Market-Place chapter at the primary stages of the novel, the narrator describes that "one symbol of shame would but poorly serve to hide another." Here the author refers to Pearl as "one symbol of shame" and ‘The Scarlet Letter’ as the other. This gives the reader the impression that Hester possesses antagonistic emotion towards her daughter, for she is the source of her ignominy and punishment. However, as the novel progresses, the reader is presented with a flourishing relationship between Hester and Pearl, symbolising how Hester is capable of change in attitude towards other characters in The Scarlet Letter. However, while Hester's change in attitude is seen as a positive transformation through the lens of moral truth within the novel, Oedipus's attitude towards the people of Thebes as well as other characters such as Creon can be seen to deteriorate into a more malicious interpretation. This is represented through the quarrel between Oedipus and Creon following their interaction with Tiresias, as Oedipus becomes paranoid that Creon is attempting to overrule him despite lacking indicative evidence. One similarity between ‘The Scarlet Letter’ and Oedipus Tyrannus in this regard can be seen through the comparison of the characters Oedipus and Dimmesdale, where both characters condemn and despise the greater society for their how they are perceived.
In conclusion, the works of ‘The Scarlet Letter’ and ‘Oedipus Tyrannus’ present characters that are both capable and incapable of changing different aspects to their identity. While Hester Prynne is shown to successfully change her internal identity as a sinner in the eyes of a morally fixed society, Oedipus is incapable of altering his true identity due to the inevitably of fate which Thebes is grounded in, presented through the dependency on divine characteristics such as prophets and prayer. Both texts also show the capability of changes to their characters public identity, with social interpretation of their characteristics changing. This is most notable in the downfall of Oedipus as his power and respect is stripped once the nature of his true identity is revealed to the people of Thebes, representing how he is capable of changing his public identity. However, ‘The Scarlet Letter’ also shows how the character of Dimmesdale is unable to change Puritan society's interpretation of his identity out of fear, despite the knowledge of what he must do to cure his aching guilt. Both writers also show changes in the characters perspective on society, with Oedipus's descent into paranoia and Hester's forgiving nature towards her daughter. Overall, the texts present how each character changes or doesn't change their identity in the face of a fixed society, whether its the strictness of the religious moral ethics of Puritan society or the inevitability of fate in Oedipus's society.
Marks and comments
Criterion A: Knowledge, understanding and interpretation (5 marks)
- How much knowledge and understanding does the candidate demonstrate of the works in relation to the question?
5 out of 5
This response demonstrates a high level of understanding and the interpretation is consistently insightful. There is a clear sense that the candidate knows the text very well.
Criterion B: Analysis and evaluation (10 marks)
Criterion B1: Analysis and Evaluation of textual features and/or authorial choices (5 marks)
- To what extent does the candidate analyse and evaluate how meaning is shaped by the choices of language, technique and style, and/or broader authorial choices?
Criterion B2: Comparative Analysis (5 marks)
- How effectively does the candidate analyse similarities and/or differences between the two works studied?
Criterion C: Focus and organisation (5 marks)
- How well structured, balanced and focused is the presentation of ideas?
4 out of 5
The essay's organisation is good, albeit with room for a more developed argument. A top mark might not have been remiss, however.
Criterion D: Language (5 marks)
- How clear, varied, and accurate is the language?
- How appropriate is the choice of register and style?
5 out of 5
Language is excellent throughout.