Home of real teaching & learning
  • Full support for teachers
  • Focus on critical thinking
  • Engaging classroom activities
  • Integrated student eBook
  • Assessed tasks / qBank
  • Practice exam questions

The InThinking Guarantee: Our sites are written by expert practitioners and not by AI

See our AI policy

Disclaimer: InThinking subject sites are neither endorsed by nor connected with the International Baccalaureate Organisation.

Don't miss out, find out!

Chapter 3c - Anti-natalist Policies

Chapter 3c - Anti-natalist Policies

This page introduces anti-natalist policy through the famous and notorious One-Child Policy in China; but to what extent was it needed? It then looks at the policies that enabled such rapid reduction in fertility rates in Bangladesh, but why is it that policies in sub-Saharan Africa have largely failed and is there room for optimism?

Syllabus

Anti-natalist policies

Resource Pressures

Controlling the rate of population growth is an important government intervention in many countries facing resource pressures. Population growth is heavily influenced by fertility rates, which are known to fall naturally with economic development. However, the pace of this economic change varies from place to place based on based on many geographical factors. Countries that experience slow economic development combined with population growth place their natural resources under increasing pressure so government intervention is needed.

China's One-Child Policy

The most well-known anti-natalist policy is China's One-child policy which was in force between 1979 and 2015. China first attempted to control its fertility through soft approaches such as nationwide family planning schemes and better access to contraception. From 1950 to 2000, China’s fertility rate fell from about 6.5 children per woman to about 1.8 children, which can only be described as an incredible achievement. However, in 1979 China adopted a far more radical approach through forced and controversial birth lists, sterilization and abortions. People living in urban areas were forced to have one child. Rural populations were exempt as well as minority ethnic groups. The graph to the right shows

Gapminder

the fall in fertility rate in China. As can be seen, as much as 80% of the decline in fertility fell through the government's soft policy approach, with an emphasis on education and family planning. The One-Child policy only appears to have had a modest impact through the 80s, before causing a more rapid decline in the 1990s. The One-Child policy is considered highly controversial as it imposed strict control over the individual's reproductive rights. Women were not allowed to conceive of their own free will. They had to strictly control pregnancy and apply to officials to be granted the right to conceive. In the case of illegal pregnancy, women endured forced abortion and the practice of forced sterilisation. Families were also subjected to higher taxation and labour market restrictions that forced people into poverty if they did not comply. China claims that the policy prevented a further 400 million people from being added to its total population. However, many demographers claim that the success of the policy is overstated and that very similar declines in fertility would have been achieved through natural change associated with economic development. In 2015, China replaced the policy with a Two-Child policy that operated in a similar way up to May 2021. 

Today, a three-child policy technically remains the official law in China, though in practice all birth limits and penalties have been eliminated. Couples are free to have as many children as they want without facing fines, and the government actively encourages larger families through financial incentives.  

ATL - Communication

Discuss as a class the merits of the One-Child Policy. For what reasons was it needed? What ethical issues do you have with it? What impact did it have on population growth? What arguments suggest it was needed?

The Bangladeshi Miracle

Highlighted in Hans Rosling's Gaminder video, the Bangladeshi Miracle, shows how government policy can achieve remarkable results in reducing fertility rates in countries of relatively low socio-economic development in a short period of time. This achievement in Bangladesh goes against the well-established view (certainly among students), that countries with low levels of education and rich religious values with conservative attitudes, struggle to embed fertility policies into practice. An example often used is the Catholic Church, which discourages the use of contraception, in order to protect the moral value of fidelity. In addition, the church fiercely defends the right to life and is against abortion, taking a pro-life stance for the 'unborn child'.  However, there is not one clear picture of how Catholics influence government policy in countries. Certainly, very Catholic countries such as Italy and Belgium don't follow a Catholic policy and have indeed adopted quite liberal secular policies. The same assumption of conservative attitudes has also been linked to other religions and contexts, such as Bangladesh, where 90% of Muslims were there.

In the case of Bangladesh, a country of 161 million people, squeezed into an area, roughly the same size as Florida, fertility rates have dropped rapidly. The graph below shows how they fell from 7 children per woman in 1970 to just 2 today.

Bangladesh is a great example: a massive population size, with one of the highest population densities in the world, exerts huge population pressure on very limited land and water resources. In 1970, Bangladesh was a population disaster of 'Malthusian' proportions waiting to happen. To this day, population and resource balance remains highly stressed, if not beyond its carrying capacity.

Bangladesh Anti-natal Policy

Health Condition: In the mid-1970s, a Bangladeshi woman on average had more than six children. In combination with poor nutrition and lack of access to quality health services, this high fertility rate jeopardised the health of both the woman and her children. Beyond the health impact, high fertility and rapid population growth represented a major constraint to the country’s economic development and social progress.

Intervention or Program: The Bangladesh family planning program was organised through a large pool of female outreach workers who visited village by village, going door-to-door to provide information, motivating families, and providing commodities; the program used mass media to stimulate a change in attitudes about family size. The program both contributed to and benefited from improvements in women’s status in Bangladesh through improved access to education and female empowerment.

Impact: As a result of the program, virtually all women in Bangladesh are now aware of modern family planning methods. The current use of contraception among married women increased from 8 per cent in the mid-1970s to about 75% in 2020, and fertility decreased from an average of more than six children per woman in 1975 to 2 in 2020. Although social and economic improvements have played a major role in increasing demand for contraception, the provision of services and information has been shown to have had an independent effect on attitudes and behaviour.

Cost and Cost-Effectiveness: The program is estimated to have cost between $100 million to $150 million per year, with about one-half to two-thirds of the funding coming from external donors. Cost-effectiveness has been estimated at about $13 to $18 per birth averted, a standard measure for family planning programs.

ATL - Communication

Referring to the Bangladesh example above, explain why its anti-natalist policies have been successful.

In what way does it show how developmental progress can be achieved through good governance at a range of scales?

Anti-Natalist Policy in Sub-Saharan Africa

Sub-Saharan Africa is well known for its high fertility rates. The region has a fertility rate of 5 children per woman, double that of the global average. Having said this fertility rate is known to fall naturally in line with a country's economic development as presented in the Demographic Transition Model. However, these countries although varied in their demographic are out of line with the model. They tend to have experienced slightly higher pre-transitional levels of fertility. There has also been a lag in the onset of transition and are transitioning at a much slower pace. The fertility rate has fallen at roughly half the pace of Asia's. The problem with persistently high fertility is that it's associated with enormous socio-economic challenges such as low living standards, low educational level and high disease burden. Only countries such as the Seychelles, Mauritius, Cape Verde, Rwanda and South Africa have been able to buck the trend in achieving faster cuts in fertility rate.

Nigeria

One example of an attempt to reduce the fertility rate can be seen in Nigeria. They introduced a National Policy for Development, Unity, Progress and Self-reliance in 1988. This policy was designed to slow down the rate of population growth and improve the standard of living for the people. It attempted, through a nationwide communication campaign to promote an awareness of population problems and the effects of rapid population growth. The campaign provided information on the benefits of small family sizes and attempted to make family planning services easily accessible to all couples at an affordable cost. It had high ambitions such as aiming to reduce teenage female marriage by 80%, and cutting the fertility rate from 3 to 2. They hoped to achieve this by reducing the number of women with four children by 80%. However, the policy has largely been a failure at the national level, achieving no real success. This can be explained by the campaign's failure to target its largely illiterate rural population. This population had a low educational base and strong traditional belief system and emphasis on religious doctrine. This coupled with high levels of community distrust in authorities, compounded by high levels of government corruption meant that reducing family size was a difficult message to absorb let alone put into action.

This example in Nigeria is not isolated in sub-Saharan Africa. For many years African leaders have failed to listen to foreign advice on controlling the fertility rate, believing it to be yet another neo-colonialist policy aimed at exploiting the continent. This led, too often to fertility issues being at best given lip service in national policy and at worst completely ignored. Demographic policy has to go hand-in-hand with wider social and economic reform and development. An integration of policy that targets grass-roots development and investment in rural communities, where the need is greatest is the only way to reduce fertility rate faster than the Demographic Transition would model. It was this integration of policy, alongside reliable international funding that brought about rapid success in Bangladesh.

Today, there does seem much greater optimism that sub-Saharan Africa can make progress in controlling its population growth. African leaders have seen the benefits of the demographic dividends gained by Asian economies in controlling fertility rates. Today there is much more global consensus and support for governments from International Governmental Organisations, development agencies and private donors. There are clear targets set in both global frameworks such as the SDGs and national frameworks, as well as more reliable international funding. African society has also moved on. They are much more integrated into the global community and this has brought about greater knowledge and aspiration as well as a growing demand for contraception. Demand stimulates the economy, creating a market force that can only further improve access to contraception and family planning services.

ATL - Communication

Essay Question  - Assess how economic and demographic factors influence the types of population policies countries adopt (10)

Revision Quiz

What percentage of the Chinese population was subjected to the historical one-child policy?

 

 

Which groups of the Chinese population were exempt from the one-child policy?

 

 

The one-child policy is thought to have reduced the Chinese population size by approximately

 

 

Why has China moved to a two-child policy?

 

 

Which of the following are true of the Bangladesh Family Planning Program 

 

 

 

By how much did China's fertility rate fall between 1970 and 2020?

 

True or False?

 

China's softer approach to reducing fertility rates was more successful than its more radical one-child policy
China's softer approach to reducing fertility rates was less successful than its more radical one-child policy

 

Which population groups were primarily affected by China's One-Child Policy?

 

What was a major controversial aspect of the One-Child Policy in China?

 

How did the Bangladesh Family Planning Program attempt to reduce fertility rates?

 

What contributed significantly to the success of Bangladesh's family planning program?

 

What were the primary factors contributing to the failure of Nigeria's population policy?

 

Which goal did Nigeria's policy aim to achieve by reducing the number of women with four children by 80%?

 

Total Score:

All materials on this website are for the exclusive use of teachers and students at subscribing schools for the period of their subscription. Any unauthorised copying or posting of materials on other platforms is an infringement of our copyright and could result in your account being blocked and legal action being taken against you.

Help